The Risks of Extended School Closures for Religious Holidays

Advertisement

Closing schools for extended periods to observe religious holidays can significantly disrupt students’ education. This concern is increasingly relevant in various contexts, particularly in ongoing discussions in the United States about whether public schools should observe Muslim holidays such as Eid al-Adha and Eid al-Fitr. As these debates unfold, the potential consequences of such closures on students’ academic progress and overall development become increasingly evident.

In northern Nigeria, the proposal to close schools for Ramadan raises similar concerns about educational access. With an average of 52.1% of children already out of school in states like Katsina, Kebbi, Kano, and Bauchi—according to the Cable Index—these closures risk exacerbating an already critical situation. In Bauchi State, where as many as 51% of children lack access to education, removing students from the classroom for weeks can lead to substantial gaps in knowledge and skills, making it difficult for them to keep pace with their peers.

The situation in the United States mirrors these challenges. Public schools traditionally recognize Christian holidays such as Christmas and Easter, prompting calls from Muslim and other religious communities for equal acknowledgment of their holidays. In New Jersey, some school districts have begun to recognize Islamic holidays, while others, such as Jersey City, have opted not to close schools for Eid al-Adha, citing logistical issues. Superintendent Marcia Lyles emphasized the importance of honoring the community’s diverse cultural and religious fabric, yet the decision leaves many students feeling marginalized.

Accommodating various religious observances also raises concerns about equity. When schools close for specific religious holidays, students from different faith backgrounds may feel excluded. For instance, if schools shut down for Ramadan, children from other religious traditions might struggle to understand the rationale behind their peers’ absences, leading to a lack of inclusivity and respect for diversity.

Successful practices from other countries offer valuable insights into how to balance religious observance with educational continuity. In Saudi Arabia, for example, schools remain open during Ramadan but adjust their hours to accommodate students’ religious practices. Classes typically run from 9 AM to 1:30 PM, allowing students to engage in their faith while ensuring they continue their education. This approach underscores the importance of maintaining a commitment to learning, even during significant religious periods.

Advertisement

The broader implications of closing schools for religious holidays extend beyond logistical challenges; they reflect a societal obligation to foster an inclusive educational environment. As public institutions, schools must strive for neutrality while ensuring that all students receive a quality education. By prioritizing education over extended celebrations, schools can create an environment where every student feels valued and included.

While observing religious holidays is important, it should not come at the expense of children’s education. Policymakers in northern Nigeria and school administrators in the United States must carefully consider the implications of closing schools for extended periods and explore alternative solutions that allow for religious observance without disrupting educational continuity.

Newspot Nigeria calls on all stakeholders to engage in meaningful dialogue about the necessity of maintaining educational access for all students. Finding a balance between faith and education that empowers the next generation rather than hinders it is crucial. The future of our children depends on it.